Donatellos 2 of west york

Joshua Butler 3 months ago

YES! I eat pizza everywhere from NY, NJ, Philly, to DC and this place is some of the best NY style pizza I've had in York County. Perfect crust. Delicious sauce. Proper cheese pull. Very good. Will be back.

David Stout 4 months ago

Stopped in and ate lunch with my kid after a soccer tournament. Kid got tenders and fries, like 6+ larger tenders and double fried "diner fries". I got a slice of pepperoni. Cant complain about anything. Nice little shop. Top notch non-sysco food. Will come back next time we are in area.

Bill Mall 4 months ago

I saw a few people mention NY/NJ pizza in their reviews, which is why I stopped in to give them a try. Expectations were exceeded! The sauce, crust, and cheese were perfect. They have quite a bit of specialty pizzas that also look delicious. I also had an Italian sub, which was very good. The sub rolls are made with pizza dough, something I do not typically care for, but this was an exception. Will be back for sure. As for the person who gave a 1 star rating because their food arrived cold and late through DoorDash, that has nothing to do with the restaurant & most likely a result of not tipping their driver. When you don't tip, it takes much longer to find a driver to accept your order, and then your food sits an gets cold. Leave a good tip next time ✌️

Daphne Minkus 5 months ago

We love Donatello’s! Good pizza is hard to come by in York county and this location is pretty convenient to York and spring grove area. We didn’t realize the original location is in Abbottstown until we stopped by on a Sunday and saw this place is closed but abbotstown is open on Sundays. Of course we trekked over! The staff and owner is so nice and welcoming, they will truly make you feel like family! My favorite might be the margarita but I still have a lot more on my bucket list to try!

David Bickford Edited 5 months ago

A 5 star experience tonight. Great food, the pizza had a very unique and great taste. Very flavorful and I could tell the sauce and cheese were what made it unique. The garlic bread was fantastic. The pasta dinners, 5 stars, and largely proportioned. We eat at a lot of restaurants, and felt the owner had prepared pasta that we felt exceeded national chain Italian restaurant main dishes. We were very happy with the selection. The Hospitality was a capital H. Very helpful, kind and generous. My daughter mentioned by the end of the family meal, she would like to bring her friends here for her upcoming birthday party as the place she takes them for dinner. Over any other choice. The family really enjoyed the experience, and are glad you opened this new restaurant and pizza shop in West York and closer to us. We highly recommend eating here.